Week 4 · Early years, 1985 to 1997
Cost of the Unmade Choice
Indecision is a courage problem wearing the costume of a thinking problem. More thinking will not cure it.
The leadership principle The Decisiveness Dividend
In any leadership team, you can usually identify the decisive members and the indecisive ones within a quarter. The decisive ones will sometimes be wrong. The wrongness will be public, recoverable, and instructive. The indecisive ones will rarely be wrong about anything, because they will rarely commit to anything firm enough to be wrong about. Their cost will not show up in the wrong column. It will show up in time. Quarters spent in deliberation that should have been spent in execution. Talent that drifted away while the seat was being deliberated. Markets that were entered six months after the window closed.
A leader’s job is not to be right at every fork in the road. A leader’s job is to make sure that the organisation moves at every fork in the road.
How do you actually do this when the decision is genuinely close? My method is simple, and I have used it for thirty years. Spend a defined amount of time on the analysis. Make a list of the pros and the cons. Work out the logical case as far as logic will take you. In my experience, logic gets you about eighty percent of the way to the answer. The last twenty percent is a leap of faith, not a logical exercise.
You take that leap of faith, and you see where you land. About four times in five, decisive action has worked in my favour. The remaining one in five was a learning that I would not have had if I had stayed paralysed at the fork.
The most expensive decisions of your career will be the ones you never made. They will not feature in any case study. They will sit quietly inside your calendar as the meetings that kept getting rescheduled, and inside your team as the people who quietly stopped expecting an answer from you.
Toolkit for the road
- 01
The 72-Hour Rule
For any pending decision that has been on your list for more than two weeks, impose a hard 72-hour deadline. At the end of 72 hours, decide. If the decision is genuinely close, accept that you are paying for the deliberation in time, and pick the option you most believe in.
Why it works. Breaks analysis paralysis and converts the cost of deliberation into a price you have consciously chosen to pay.
- 02
The Indecision Log
For one quarter, keep a running list of decisions that get deferred in your leadership meetings. Next to each, note the date it first came up and the date it was finally made. Review the log at the end of the quarter and tally the cumulative weeks of unresolved time.
Why it works. Quantifies a cost the management accounts will never show and forces honest conversation about which decisions the team is silently outsourcing back to you.
- 03
The Five-Year Test
When you are paralysed on a difficult call, ask one question: if I look back at this after five years from now, am I more likely to regret making the wrong move, or to regret never having made one? In my experience, the second regret is heavier.
Why it works. Reframes the choice from a risk-of-failure problem into a cost-of-time problem, which is the framing that matches reality.
Keep reading
Similar lessons
The mediocre strategist plans for the defensive move. The good one plans for the winning move. The best one plans for the move that the opponent is likely to make. Week 3 The Chessboard Mindset Clarity as a Weapon Read lesson
The amateur plays every hand to the end. The professional folds early, because the bankroll is what buys the next ten hands. Week 16 Knowing When to Fold Intelligent Reallocation Read lesson
The leader who refuses to switch altitudes will eventually fail in two directions at once. Week 39 The Zoom-In, Zoom-Out Balance Dual-Lens Operating Read lesson
