Week 38 · Scaling Mirum, 2014 to 2023
The Luxury of Failure
Failure is not the price of innovation. It is the dividend on scale. The founder who refuses to spend it is hoarding currency that no longer earns interest.
The leadership principle Strategic Risk Capacity
Scale buys you a portfolio. A portfolio buys you the right to be wrong about some of its bets. The leader who does not exercise that right is wasting the most expensive asset their growth has produced. The leader who exercises it without discipline is squandering the same asset.
Mature operators recognise the difference between bets that are existential, bets that are tuitional, and bets that are decorative. The first must be made with extreme care. The second must be made regularly, ring-fenced, and learned from. The third must be killed before they consume oxygen.
Toolkit for the road
- 01
The Annual Experiment Budget
At the start of each financial year, set aside a defined percentage of profit – three to five percent works for most service businesses – explicitly earmarked for experiments. The number is published. The team knows it exists.
Why it works. Removes the case-by-case begging that kills most experiments before they start. Pre-commits the firm to bet, before the courage to bet has run out.
- 02
The Sandbox Rule
Every experimental initiative gets its own budget, its own owner, and a clear ceiling. It cannot pull people from the cash cow without a documented, time-bound exception. It either graduates to the main business or sunsets cleanly.
Why it works. Protects the operational engine while giving the new room to breathe. Most experiments die not because the idea was wrong but because the cash cow ate them.
- 03
The Tuition Review
For every experiment that did not work, hold a detailed review six months after the close. Document what was learned. Circulate the document. Treat it as a paid-for lesson, not a closed file.
Why it works. Converts failed bets into compounding institutional knowledge. The cost was already paid; the only question is whether the return on the cost is harvested.
Keep reading
Similar lessons
It may not be your fault the factory burned down. It is entirely your responsibility to rebuild it. Week 17 The Rationalisation Trap Accountability to Self Read lesson
Failure is the most expensive education available. Most people pay the fees and never collect the degree. Week 15 The Asset of Failure Sweat to Gold Read lesson
Markets fall faster than they rise. Build for the fall before it arrives. Week 13 The Speed of the Fall The Architecture of Resilience Read lesson
